EU Regulator Sees No Safety Problem With A350 Paint at Center of Legal Dispute

Article

Europe’s top aviation safety regulator said on Tuesday he had seen no evidence that paint or surface erosion on A350 jets, which are at the center of a legal dispute between Airbus and Qatar Airways, represented a safety issue.

The two companies are at loggerheads over the airworthiness of Europe’s newest long-haul jet after damage to its protective outer skin exposed a damaged layer of lightning protection and prompted Qatar to ground more than 20 of the jets.

Airbus, backed by the European Union Aviation Safety Agency (EASA), has acknowledged quality flaws with the jets at several airlines but denies that the problems amount to a safety risk, maintaining that there is ample backup lightning protection.

Qatar Airways Suffers UK Court Setback in Feud With Airbus

Qatar Airways, backed by its own national regulator, which has ordered the jets to be taken out of service as the problem appears, insists that the safety impact cannot be properly understood until Airbus provides deeper technical analysis.

In an unprecedented London court battle, it is pursuing Airbus for more than $1 billion in damages, with the value of the carrier’s claim rising by $4 million per day.

On Tuesday, the head of EASA defended the agency’s stance on the A350 when asked during a visit to the United States whether the long-haul aircraft’s safety remained intact.

“We have inspected the airplane. We saw no damage which could imply safety issues,” the agency’s executive director Patrick Ky told reporters on the sidelines of an air safety conference in Washington.

Airlines Meeting

In a statement two weeks ago, Qatar Airways said it believed “the impact of the condition on safety of the affected aircraft can only be established once (it) has been properly investigated and the full root cause conclusively established.”

Barring a settlement, the two sides are heading towards a three-month trial starting in June next year after a British judge called for the matter to be brought to a head as quickly as possible, noting it had industry implications worldwide.

Drawing on detailed extracts from the judge’s preliminary ruling, Qatar Airways has indicated it plans to demonstrate that the A350’s problems stem from fundamental design decisions.

Airbus has argued that premature paint erosion is a feature of the carbon-composite technology used to build all modern long-haul jets – a necessary trade-off for its weight savings.

The dispute also provides a contentious backdrop to a global meeting of airline chiefs due to take place in Qatar in coming days. Airbus Chief Executive Guillaume Faury will attend the June 19-21 Doha meeting of the International Air Transport Association, hosted by Qatar Airways CEO Akbar Al Baker.

Other airlines are continuing to fly the A350 after European regulators said the widespread surface problem did not affect safety. Privately, however, several airline chiefs told Reuters both sides must find common ground.

As of now, there are no visible signs of a settlement.

The dispute has if anything widened after Airbus revoked a separate contract with Qatar for its smaller A321neos in January.

Qatar Airways has said the move to punish the airline over the A350 by canceling a separate deal sets a worrying market precedent but Airbus says it was obeying its contractual rights.

(Reporting by David Shepardson and Tim Hepher; editing by Gerry Doyle and Richard Pullin)

Photograph: A Qatar Airways plane lands at King Khalid Airport in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, on Monday, Jan. 11, 2021. Airbus says it has terminated a multibillion dollar order by Qatar Airways for 50 of its single-aisle A321neo jets. The termination of the contract comes as the planemaker and its major Gulf customer, Qatar Airways, are embroiled in a legal dispute in London over the grounding of the larger Airbus A350 aircraft by the Gulf-based airline. Photo credit: AP Photo/Amr Nabil, File.

Related: